about us

JURY VERDICT: $9,400,000

Robert W. Johnson & Associates was retained to present testimony that would assist the jury in quantifying (a) the loss of enjoyment of life suffered by the 13 year old plaintiff; and (b) the economic impact of this trauma on the young female's earning capacity. In addition, Robert W. Johnson & Associates was asked to prepare a LIFE ACTIVITY CALENDAR, based on lay trial testimony, that would graphically illustrate how the injury has changed her life.

Location: Los Angeles, California

Case: Diaz, et al., v. City of Los Angeles.

Court: Los Angeles County, California Superior Court, No. C750680.

Plaintiff’s Attorneys: Attorneys Cochran and Ferrer, Law Offices of Johnnie L. Cochran, Jr., Los Angeles, California.

Judge: William Drake

Case Synopsis: Ms. Patricia Diaz, a 13-year-old, was sexually molested by a Los Angeles City policeman in January, 1989. The policeman was arrested and convicted shortly thereafter. As a result of her trauma, Ms. Diaz suffered severe psychological deterioration which included Post Traumatic Stress Syndrome. In addition, she attempted suicide on three occasions. Her psychologist (assuming maximum recovery), rated her permanent loss of enjoyment of life, using the Global Assessment Functioning Scale (GAF), in the range of 33% to 44%.

Expert Testimony: Robert W. Johnson testified that, (a) combining Ms. Diaz's medical loss of enjoyment of life rating of 33% to 44%, coupled with the federal government studies and accepted economic analysis (that the dollar value of the 100% loss of enjoyment of life ranges between $1.6 and $8.5 million), the range for Ms. Diaz's loss of enjoyment of life was $530,000 to $3,7000,000; and (b) assuming that Ms. Diaz's earnings capacity was reduced by a percentage identical to her GAF deficit of 33% to 44%, her earnings capacity was reduced by $509,000 (if a high school graduate) and $919,000 (if a college graduate).

For closing argument, a color-coded LIFE ACTIVITY CALENDAR, illustrating the before and after effects of her injury, was prepared based on the actual testimony of Ms. Diaz and her parents.

For More Information....

Catastrophic Injury Cases:

  • Los Angeles Jury Awards $9.2 Million, Including $6 Million in Punitive Damages, to Living Cancer Victim. Read More...
  • Economist Quantifies Damages to Homemaker in Tobacco Case. Read More...
  • Economist Testimony Assists Jury in Verdict Against General Motors. Read More...
  • Life Activity Calendar Supports Jury Verdict in Fast-Food Slip and Fall. Read More...
  • Economist Quantifies Secretary's Loss of Enjoyment of Life in Soft Tissue Case. Read More...
Related Services: Order Services Now:
  • Wage Loss, Personal Injury Valuation Form... Order Now
  • Life Activity Calendar, Personal Injury Checklist... Order Now
  • Loss of Enjoyment of Life, Personal Injury Valuation... Order Now

Attorney Comments: "Damages were the core of this case. Your highly credible testimony on Ms. Diaz's loss of enjoyment of life and lost earnings capacity gave the jury a logical, rational, and understandable way to quantify this difficult area of damages. During cross examination, it was especially delightful when you engaged defense counsel in a discussion on where Ms. Diaz belonged in the loss of enjoyment of life calculation chart. The two defense economists credibility was irreparably damaged by your answers during cross examination.

The quick production of the color-coded LIFE ACTIVITY CALENDAR, based on actual trial testimony, enabled us to visually and powerfully summarize how this tragedy has drained the color out of Ms. Diaz's life."

Results: The defense offered less than $150,000 pre-trial and asked for a defense verdict. The jury returned a verdict of $9,400,000 (almost identical to the plaintiff's summation presentation) which consisted of $3,100,000 in punitive damages; and $6,300,000 in compensatory damages (pain and suffering/loss of enjoyment of life/lost earnings capacity).